A toilet seat is one of the vital components of your toilet system, and you always want to choose the best that will guarantee comfort, cleanliness and ease. For many people, choosing the best toilet seat is a top priority, but they often don't know how to make the selection.
We've made the whole process easier for you with our buying guide, along with a comprehensive list of the best toilet seats. Read on to get started.
The Best Toilet Seat Buying Guide
Buying a new toilet seat can be a daunting experience, and unless you're a seasoned homeowner, you are more likely to make the wrong buy. To help you get it right the first time, here are some factors to consider when choosing a toilet rim/ toilet seat.
When looking for a toilet seat, you must pay attention to the seat's shape. If you are keen enough, you might have noticed that toilet bowls have slightly varying shapes. Some are rounded, while others are a bit oval or elongated.
Most elongated and round toilets have the same flushing power, water usage, height, and even ease of installation. However, the shape of the toilet bowl may impact the overall appearance of your bathroom, the ease of cleaning, space utilization, and comfort.
You should pick either the elongated or round versions based on the shape of your toilet bowl. Both elongated and round toilets have their own pros and cons, but the elongated type has gained popularity among many homeowners over the years. That said, elongated types are more comfortable, thanks to the increased surface area.
If you are renovating your bathroom and considering a new toilet seat, take note of the shape of the current seat to ensure compatibility. Both elongated and round toilet seats come with several other features, such as padded or heated surfaces for extra comfort; hence your choice will not be limited to the shape.
Comfort and Convenience
When it comes to comfort and convenience, there's a lot to consider. First, ensure the toilet seat you want to buy serves the people you are buying for. For instance, a smaller seat is ideal for babies and younger children, while a cushioned toilet seat is ideal for the elderly or people with conditions such as sciatica. Here are some more options for the small toilets available in market. Another thing to consider is whether the seat comes with tight bumpers.
Many toilet seats in the market slid during use because they lack bumpers. The latter helps the seat remain firm when you sit on it. In other words, a toilet seat without bumpers means the hinges are under stress every time you sit on it, and the hinges may eventually break.
In addition, these bumpers should be of good quality, i.e., they should lock the seat in place, preventing unnecessary movements. Some of the best brands have up to four bumpers to ensure your weight is well distributed on the seat, helping avoid undue pressure on the hinges and the seat itself.
For a pleasant bathroom experience and extra comfort, you can go for the heated seats, which are ideal for winter. However, you should also check the toilet seat bolts to make sure they are compatible with the design of your existing toilet.
That said, many toilet seats are of standard size, but some may need some bit of re-adjusting, and it would be a good idea to have the exact dimensioning. Additionally, make sure the screws, bolts, and nuts allow for quick removal if you need to do some thorough cleaning.
Material and Durability
A toilet seat can be made of any material – from molded wood, durable plastic to enameled wood – and you can always choose one that best suits your needs. Nowadays, most toilet seats are made of polypropylene, a stain, chip, crack, and scratch-resistant material.
Wooden toilet seats are also gaining acceptance in the market, especially among consumers who prefer earth-friendly materials. However, it's worth noting that wooden seats aren't entirely made of wood; instead, they only have a wooden core.
On the other hand, molded wood seats are made of MDF (medium-density fiberboards). Another cheaper alternative is a wooden seat coated in plastic. These seats, unlike plastics, could be your perfect fit if you are looking for elegance and a more environmentally friendly option.
When it comes to durability, molded wood, unlike MDF, is more reliable. Plastic hinges are also less durable than stainless steel hinges. Another important consideration is to look for a toilet seat with quick-release hinges for quick removal where need be.
Soft Close Feature
This is one of the critical aspects that will determine how your toilet seat closes. Old school toilet seats had no technology or mechanisms to avoid slamming and loud noise. However, over the years, soft close mechanisms have been incorporated into the design.
Nowadays, a seat with this technology closes slowly without any noise. And while soft close toilet seats may be a bit costly, they are definitely worth the money in the long run.
Cleansing Toilet Seat
This is one of the premium features offered by a few toilet seat brands. There are several designs, and some come with a shower nozzle only, while others are fitted with a warm air dryer. These types are more hygienic and more environmentally friendly since toilet paper isn't needed.
Most cleansing toilet seats come equipped with a soft close mechanism, a heated surface, etc. For an enhanced bathroom experience, you can pick a padded toilet seat or one fitted with LED nightlights.
Now that you know the factors to consider when buying a toilet seat, we've picked the ten best toilet seats based on the above features.
10 Best Toilet Seats in the market
1. Kohler K 4636 Cachet Toilet Seat
This is one of the best if not the best toilet seat in the market, thanks to the many great features you can expect of a premium product. First, this seat is made from frozen polypropylene that's guaranteed to withstand chipping, stains, fade, and other wear and tear forces.
Innovative features such as the soft-close technology mean the seat slowly closes with the slightest touch, eliminating the annoying slamming sound.
The seat also comes with tight bumpers that hold the seat in place and the quick release hinges allow for quick removal of the seat for cleaning purposes.
- It comes in multiple colors to suit your bathroom design.
- Features quick-release hinges for easy use and faster cleaning.
- Kohler's quiet-close technology eliminates the accidental slamming and potential damage to your toilet seat.
- Available both in elongated and round designs.
- The seat comes with a one-year lifetime limited warranty.
- This toilet is made of plastic, and that could be a deal-breaker for some people.
2. Mayfair Whisper Close Molded Wood
Made from molded wood and designed for class and elegance, the Mayfair Whisper-close comes with a high gloss finish that can withstand chipping and scratching.
The quick-release hinges allow for easy removal, while the whisper-close design eliminates any accidental slamming or pinched fingers. And unlike other types that require tools during installation, this brand comes with change hinges, where you simply rotate the securing latches that cover the bolt heads.
Since molded wood is a robust material, this seat can accommodate even the “heavy-weights” without exposing the hinges to undue pressure. The wood material is another plus, especially for environmentally aware customers.
- The molded wood material is very robust.
- It fits both elongated and round toilet bowls.
- The Change hinges guarantee easy removal and subsequently easy cleaning.
- Closes slowly and quietly hence the name “whisper.”
- The first-time installation could be hectic
3. TOTO SS-154#01 Elongated Toilet Seat
This type features a traditional yet robust design, thanks to the solid polypropylene – a rigid, tough, and highly durable plastic material. A high gloss finish stands up to high traffic, and it's resistant to water, contaminants, and dirt.
Since the material is also light-reflecting and super shiny, this seat gives your toilet a classic mirror-like look and could be a great complement to your bathroom décor. Here are some more options on the best TOTO toilets in 2021. You can pick from this list whatever is suitable for you.
Being elongated in shape, the TOTO SS-154 guarantees extra comfort while the molded bumpers keep the seat in place to avoid slippage, which could strain the hinges. Installing this seat is a no-brainer since it comes with all the hardware.
During installation, you'll realize that everything has been designed to fall into place, so you won't have to worry about identifying parts or some hectic trial and error.
As one of the slow close seats in the market, the TOTO SS-154 ensures quiet operation without little to no wear or potential damage due to slamming.
Additionally, this seat comes in five different colors, unlike the other products in the market. This is an added advantage for people conscious of their toilet system's colors and overall appearance.
- This is a durable soft close toilet seat.
- It's easy to install
- Available in five distinct colors – cotton white, bone, colonial white, Sedona beige, and Ebony.
- A bit expensive
4. Delta Faucet Morgan Slow-close Round Toilet Seat
The Delta faucet round toilet seat is one of the affordable types in the market that offers near-premium features, so it's a good buy for someone on a budget.
This seat is designed and manufactured by Delta Faucet, a reputed brand, and you can always bet on the quality and durability of its plastic products.
The seat comes with bumpers to prevent slippage and to protect the hinges from damage. In addition, the quiet close design means there's no slamming or pinched fingers, and you'll only need to flip the lid with a touch of your finger.
Another important feature of this slow-close seat is the durable finish designed to withstand stains, chipping, fading, or peeling. This means that maintaining this toilet seat is less of a hassle.
Delta faucet is available in two types, i.e., rounded and elongated, and you can always choose one that matches your toilet. Installing this seat is easy since it comes with all the nuts and bolts you need for a quick and seamless assembly.
- Reasonable price.
- The medium-quality plastic is durable and affordable
- Easy to install.
- Its quiet-close system may not be very durable.
5. Brondell-L60EB Luma-Warm Heated Toilet Seat
The Brondell-L60EB is a luxury toilet seat that features high-end features for extra comfort and convenience. The seat comes in two distinct shapes to fit both the elongated and round toilets.
The robust design features a heated seat and midnight LED, which you can use at night while you're half asleep – i.e., instead of blinding yourself with the bright bathroom lights.
With four heating settings, you can choose any temperature depending on the weather and your personal preference. That means you won't have to suffer the shock and discomfort of sitting on an ice-cold seat again.
Besides these luxury features, the Brondell- L60EB comes with a quiet close system, and you won't have to worry about slamming your luxury toilet seat.
As far as color options are concerned, you'll find this seat in two colors, white and biscuit, and you can pick one that best suits your toilet's overall design. If you want to buy a new toilet seat with all the high-end features, the Brondell-L60EB is your perfect upgrade pick.
- It comes with all the high-end features for added convenience.
- Features a comfortable ergonomic design
- With all the features, this seat is expensive
- It's not compatible with most toilets
6. Mayfair 9601-CP Natural Reflection Veneer
This is a wooden toilet seat with a natural and robust oak finishing that gives it a shiny look. The seat is comfortable at best, and the robust finish can withstand years of abrasion, wears, and accidental slams.
In addition, the natural reflections from this seat make it an excellent option for homeowners with a taste for colors and interior design.
The seat also fits comfortably into either the round or elongated toilet, even those from different manufacturers. But to be on the safer side, you want to have the exact measurements with you just in case you're using a more traditional or unique Non-American brand.
If you are looking to try something fresh, new, and unique, the Mayfair 9601-CP could be your perfect pick.
However, like any other wooden toilet seat, the Mayfair 9601-CP requires proper maintenance to ensure high hygiene levels and keep it in the best working conditions. For instance, the weight of the wood may damage the hinges over time if you don't handle it with care, especially when cleaning the seat.
- The natural oak finishing offers a sturdier feel than plastic seats.
- The seat fits most toilets – i.e., both rounded and elongated toilets.
- This toilet seat is easy to install.
- The bumpers supporting the seat in place are weak.
7. Bemis 7800 TD-G000 Plastic Toilet Seat
Unlike all the other brands on this list, the Bemis 7800 TD doesn't have many sophisticated features to show off. However, it's highly functional, durable, and affordable.
This seat doesn't come with fancy design features such as the slow close mechanism or high-end surface finish; instead, it's simple and unique in its own right.
If you are looking for an affordable, high-quality plastic toilet seat, the Bemis 7800 could be your best bet. Besides being plain and simple, the toilet seat is widely accepted in the market. When installed properly, this seat will stay in place without the need for constant re-tightening or readjustments.
If you would instead choose a more robust material, you can pick or upgrade to the Bemis 1500 EC, a durable enameled wood seat – made from one of the earth-friendly materials that's scratch and chip resistant. Both these two models offer an easy installation, are durable and comfortable.
- Made of highly durable plastic
- The toilet seat comes with a steady fastening system to ensure easy installation and easy removal.
- It's a perfect fit for someone on a budget.
- It doesn't come with the quiet-close technology
8. Mayfair 115EC Toilet Seat
This a premium product made entirely of wood and characterized by adjustable hinges. In addition, it features a quiet close system that prevents slamming of the lid. Among the other features include adjustable hinges that make it possible to install the seat on any toilet type.
The wood material is robust and resistant to scratches or chipping, and the installation manual makes the assembly process more straightforward.
This product, unlike the other toilet seats in the market, features a premium STA-TITE fastening system. The latter is a patented hinge-fixing system that solves the problem with wobbly or loose fixtures common in high-traffic areas.
That way, it guarantees faster and safer installation while ensuring comfort during use. Besides this innovative system, the 115EC doesn't come with any other special features considering its premium price; it may be considered a bit costly.
- It comes with durable hinges
- Features a reliable fastening system
- It fits several toilets such as Toto, Kohler, and other American-Standard toilets.
- It works with either a round or elongated toilet.
- It's a bit costly.
- It doesn't come with a slow-close mechanism.
9. Kohler K-4694 Molded-Wood Toilet Seat
This is one of the well-designed products in the market, thanks to its compatibility with several toilet brands and designs such as two-piece and one-piece toilets.
Besides being comfortable and robust, it features several color options to ensure you aren't messing up your toilet system with non-matching colors.
Installing this toilet seat is easy and straightforward, provided you captured your measurements right. All you need is a screwdriver to tighten the screws and get the nuts in place – avoiding any uncomfortable movements during use. Apart from the ingenious design and durable hinges, the molded wood material offers a sturdier feel and look.
- Compatible with most toilet brands
- Features molded wood, which is highly durable.
- The pricing is reasonable.
- The toilet seat may lose its stain-resistant feature with time.
10. Vive Toilet seat with Handles for Handicapped
If you or a family member have just undergone surgery or has mobility and posture issues, this toilet seat would be of great help. This type features two handles with padded arms for extra support and comfort.
Besides being portable and aesthetically appealing, this seat is easy to install. In fact, you won't need any tools, and the best part is that it fits both the round and elongated toilet seats.
That said, you still need to measure your toilet bowl or current seat to avoid too much deviation, which could cause stability issues. Due to the added features, this toilet seat is a bit expensive.
- Ideal for disabled and elderly persons.
- It features a tool-free installation.
- It fits both round and elongated toilets.
- It's costly.
- It doesn't feature quick-release hinges or any soft-close technology.
What is the best toilet seat to buy?
The best toilet seat for you'll depend on your own needs. If you are on a budget and looking for a durable toilet seat without fancy features, Bemis 7800 TD would be ideal. However, if you are looking for the best value toilet seat for the money, Kohler k 4636 would be your best pick.
Typically, an ideal toilet seat has a durable finish, is easy to install, and has non-slip bumpers, among other features. A rule of thumb is to pick a couple of brands that meet your expectations before making some thorough comparisons.
Are plastic or wood toilet seats better?
When it comes to choosing between wood or plastic material, there's no right or wrong answer. Wood and plastic have their advantages and disadvantages, and you may want to consider other features before making up your mind.
For instance, molded wood is more reliable than ordinary plastic but less durable compared to frozen polypropylene. Similarly, plastic offers more color options than ordinary wood and molded wood.
If you are on a tight budget and your buying decision depends more on the price tag, then a medium-strength plastic would be great. However, you don't want to sacrifice essential features such as bumpers and quick-release hinges since they determine the functionality, safety, and ease of using the toilet seat.
Which is better elongated or round toilet seats?
When choosing the shape of your toilet seat, you want to make sure it fits perfectly on the toilet bowl. Both elongated and round toilet seats come with their pros and cons.
For instance, elongated/oval seats are easy to clean and offer more sitting space but aren't suitable for washrooms with limited space. They are also a bit expensive.
On the other hand, round toilets or round toilet seats are perfect for bathrooms with limited space and are pocket-friendly but maybe less comfortable and challenging to clean. Therefore, before comparing the options in the market, you should know how to differential between elongated and round toilet seats.
While many people can quickly tell round toilets from elongated toilets, it might not be that obvious for some. If you can't easily distinguish between the two, you should measure from the front of the toilet bowl to somewhere at the center of the mounting holes.
For example, an elongated toilet seat measures 18.5″ while a round seat measures 16.5.” You can then compare your toilet bowl measurements to the standards sizes of toilet seats and choose one that will fit perfectly.
Choosing the best toilet seat narrows down to your own needs, taste, and personal preference. A rule of thumb is to know what you want before sorting through the many options in the market.
For instance, if your priority is to enhance your bathroom experience, investing a bit more in a padded or heated toilet seat would be a good idea. However, if you are in for a basic yet functional toilet seat, plastic or molded wood type would be your best pick.