The Pros And Cons Of A Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

Jump to Section

Key Takeaway:

  • Pros of a kitchen cabinet replacement: A cabinet replacement can update the look and feel of your kitchen, increase storage space and functionality, and add value to your home. It can also be more cost-effective than a full kitchen remodel.
  • Cons of a kitchen cabinet replacement: A cabinet replacement can be a time-consuming and messy process that involves dismantling and disposing of the old cabinets, and installing the new ones. It can also be expensive, especially if custom cabinets are desired.
  • Considerations for a kitchen cabinet replacement: Before deciding on a cabinet replacement, it's important to consider factors such as budget, timeline, and the scope of the project. It's also important to work with a reputable contractor who can provide quality materials and installation services.Wondering about a kitchen cabinet replacement? Don't worry! This article will give you a detailed overview of the advantages and drawbacks. You'll learn more about the effects of a kitchen cabinet change, plus what rewards you can expect. Get the info you need to make a smart choice!

Understanding Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

Kitchen cabinets are a crucial element in any kitchen, both for functionality and aesthetics. When remodeling a kitchen, the option of replacing old cabinets with new ones arises. In this section, we’ll dive into the ins and outs of a kitchen cabinet replacement.

First, we will answer the question, “What is a kitchen cabinet replacement?“, and clarify what this process entails. Then, we will expand on the various aspects of kitchen cabinet replacement to give you a better understanding of its pros and cons.

What is a kitchen cabinet replacement?

Kitchen cabinet replacement is a great way to upgrade your kitchen without spending a lot. It involves swapping old parts like doors, handles, drawer fronts, plinths, end panels, and carcass with new, made-to-measure components.

Pros include a modern look, cost savings, ease, design help, high-quality woods (cherry, maple, ash, hickory, oak), and lacquer cabinets for a sleek finish.

Cons include labor costs, risk of damage if not done by experts, warping or soft spots if wood is not seasoned correctly, and the chance of poor quality cabinets developing mold.

To decide if kitchen cabinet replacement is right for you, get a free quote from a specialist who offers made-to-measure components, quality wood, and a variety of designs.

Overall, this is a great way to give your kitchen a brand new look, saving time and money.

Advantages of a Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

Thinking about remodeling your kitchen and wondering whether a kitchen cabinet replacement is worth the investment? In this section, let's focus on the advantages of upgrading your kitchen cabinets. Beyond the obvious aesthetic improvements, there are multiple functional benefits to a kitchen cabinet replacement. Throughout this section, we will explore each of the advantages: improved functionality and storage space, enhanced aesthetic appeal and home value, and the customization options that allow for personalized upgrades to your kitchen. Get ready to learn how a new set of kitchen cabinets can help transform the heart of your home.

Improved functionality and storage space

Replacing kitchen cabinets can be a great way to boost functionality and storage space. It can also give your kitchen a brand-new, stylish look without breaking the bank.


  • You can get improved storage and layout features.
  • There's a wide range of stylish and contemporary designs to choose from.
  • Product options include RTF, wood veneer, plastic laminates, and made-to-measure cabinets.
  • It's cheaper than a full kitchen remodel and can address soft spots caused by deterioration.
  • Refinishing or repainting is more expensive.
  • It's a stress-free process with a complete replacement.


  • It can get messy with cabinet removal and installation.
  • Cost considerations depend on size and the number of cabinets.
  • It can be difficult to match the new cabinets to existing décor.
  • Layout changes may be hard to achieve with a small kitchen or bathroom.

Overall, replacing cabinets has many advantages, but careful consideration should be taken before making a decision. Adding a new look to your kitchen can be great, especially when it meets your needs.

Enhanced aesthetic appeal and home value

Kitchen cabinet replacement projects can really upgrade your kitchen's look and improve your home's value. Reports show that kitchen remodels result in an 80% return of investment, making it one of the most cost-effective home improvement projects. With new cabinet doors and made-to-measure products, you can get the same look for much less money.

Benefits of Kitchen Cabinet Replacement:

  1. Cost-Saving & Time-Saving – Refurbishing with new cabinets is a great way to get the same look without full renovation costs.
  2. Varied Products – There's a range of kitchen cabinets with lots of design options. Pick the perfect ones for your style and budget.
  3. Structural Upgrades – Replacing soft spots in your cabinets gives them a durable upgrade and longer lifespan.
  4. Increased Aesthetic Appeal & Home Value – Replacing your kitchen cabinets creates a fresh look, which increases your home's value.


  1. Limited Options – Refinishing or refacing the cabinets only lets you change certain aspects.
  2. Design Difference – The new design may not match your existing one. To avoid this, consult with a design expert.

Pro Tip: Kitchen cabinet replacement is a great way to modernize your kitchen. Talk to the experts to find out how you can get a beautiful, functional, and modern kitchen for a fraction of the cost of a full remodel.

Customization options and personalization

A kitchen cabinet replacement has lots of awesome advantages. From picking kitchen cabinet doors that are made-to-measure to having a cost-effective option compared to a full kitchen refurbishment – it's a winner! Plus, you can fix issues like outdated colors, soft spots and structural issues with new cabinets – no money wasted.

It's important to hire experienced specialists who can install and customize the cabinets. They will make sure the new cabinets are beautiful, long-lasting and custom-fit your kitchen.

In conclusion, the benefits of a kitchen cabinet replacement are clear. If you want to upgrade your kitchen without spending too much time and money, it's the way to go!

Disadvantages of a Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

While upgrading your kitchen cabinets can enhance the overall look and functionality of your space, it’s not without its drawbacks. In this section, we’ll take a closer look at the disadvantages of a kitchen cabinet replacement project. We’ll analyze the expense and time investment required for such a project, as well as the potential risks of damage to pre-existing countertops and fixtures. Additionally, we’ll explore the messy and disruptive installation process that can make kitchen cabinet replacement a daunting undertaking. It’s essential to consider these downsides before committing to a full-scale cabinet replacement project.

The Pros and Cons of a Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

Expensive and time-consuming process

Replacing kitchen cabinets can be pricey and take a lot of time. It typically costs from $12,000 to $21,000. Plus, it can take several weeks. Plus, your options are limited. And, structural changes may be needed, which adds cost. Think carefully before deciding to replace kitchen cabinets. Research is key!

Potential for damage to existing countertops and fixtures

Replacing kitchen cabinets can be risky. Damage to existing countertops and fixtures is a potential drawback. This risk is especially high with made-to-measure cabinets, as they might require a new kitchen layout. Plus, labor and materials can be costly. Removing old cabinets and installing new ones is laborious and physically demanding. Prices of cabinets vary too, making it tricky to choose.

The potential benefits of a new kitchen (improved functionality and home value) must be weighed against expenses and risks. Before committing, assess your options and budget. Existing cabinets may need repair first, which adds time and cost. To avoid damage, hire a professional contractor.

To add authority, figures or stats could be included – such as the average cost of a kitchen cabinet replacement or the percentage of installations that result in damage to existing fixtures and countertops.

Messy and disruptive installation process

Kitchen cabinet replacement can be a messy and disruptive job. It can take days or even weeks to finish, depending on the size and complexity. Plus, custom-made cabinets may be needed, increasing the cost. Labor can also be expensive if the job takes longer.

But, there are benefits. An updated product range and structural improvements can be gained. Yet, structural changes could reveal soft spots needing more repair or replacement.

Weigh the pros and cons carefully before making a decision. Be prepared for disruption and mess, but also the potential benefits to the kitchen's look and function.

Facts and stats:

  • In 2019, the global market size of kitchen cabinets amounted to 17.9 billion USD.
  • According to a survey conducted by Houzz in 2020, 64% of homeowners cited “improving design and functionality” as the main reason for renovating their kitchen, while 33% cited “increasing home value.”
  • The average cost of a kitchen remodel in the US is around $25,000.

Five Facts About the Pros and Cons of a Kitchen Cabinet Replacement:

  • ✅ Upgrading kitchen cabinets can increase home value by up to 80% ROI. (Source: HomeLight)
  • ✅ A full kitchen cabinet replacement can cost up to $25,000. (Source: HomeAdvisor)
  • ✅ Refacing or resurfacing existing cabinets can cost around $4,000. (Source: HGTV)
  • ✅ Choosing the right materials, such as solid wood or laminate, can affect the durability and longevity of kitchen cabinets. (Source: This Old House)
  • ✅ The decision to replace or reface kitchen cabinets should also consider the layout and functionality of the current space. (Source: Better Homes & Gardens)

FAQs about The Pros And Cons Of A Kitchen Cabinet Replacement

What are the pros and cons of a kitchen cabinet replacement?

The pros and cons of a kitchen cabinet replacement project can be a big investment, so you should think about the pros and cons before making a decision. One benefit is that it can make your kitchen look and feel completely different. A replacement can also raise the value of your home. On the other hand, you have to think about the cost of labor, and it may not always be worth it.

What is made-to-measure and why is it important?

Made-to-measure refers to a garment or product that is specifically tailored to an individual's unique measurements and specifications. Made-to-measure is important because it allows individuals to have clothing that fits them perfectly and flatters their body shape. With made-to-measure clothing, there is no need to settle for standard sizes that may not fit correctly or to have clothing altered after purchase.

How can cost benefits be calculated?

Cost benefits can be calculated based on the age and condition of your current cabinets. If your current cabinets aren't very sturdy and aren't very good quality, it might be cheaper to just get new ones instead of fixing the soft spots. But if the cabinets you already have are still in good shape and only have small problems, it may be cheaper to just fix them up or reface them.

What are the possible labor costs involved in a cabinet replacement?

The possible labor costs involved in a cabinet replacement can range from $3,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on the size and complexity of the project. It is important to get quotes from several contractors and to ask for references before making a decision on who to hire for the job.

What are cabinet soft spots?

Cabinet soft spots are places on the cabinet that wear down easily, like the doors, handles, hinges, and drawer slides. When you look at your cabinets, you can see if there are any soft spots or structural damage. Before starting a replacement project, it's important to fix any soft spots and structural damage. This will make sure that the new cabinets last a long time.

Dino Paccino

Dino Paccino

Dino is a lifelong writer and home improvement specialist. He enjoys bringing cutting-edge information on home renovation and remodeling to Kitchen Infinity.

Related Articles

Download Free Chart Now!

Your email will be used only to confirm your request and to provide free kitchen information. By submitting your info on this form, you are agreeing to be contacted regarding your service request by means of email. This is no obligation form and doesn’t require you to purchase any service.