Why Does My Toilet Flush Sometimes And Not Others: Five Reason Why And How To Fix It

Jump to Section

For homeowners, an irregular toilet flush can be an irritating issue. To maintain adequate hygiene and prevent blockages, you must have a toilet that flushes consistently. So, you probably know how flushing toilets work but are wondering “why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others?” Well, there are a couple of causes.

My toilet flush sometimes
Picture by: Thespruce.com

Cause 1: Low Water Level in the Tank

In order for the toilet to operate effectively, a complicated system of several parts called toilet plumbing must be in place. The toilet tank, which stores the water needed for flushing, is one essential part. The fill valve, which fills the tank with water after each flush, is what connects the tank to the plumbing. Very little water in the tank can result in a number of issues, such as weak or ineffective flushing as well as clogging or other issues with the toilet bowl water level adjustment.

How the Toilet Tank Functions

It's important to comprehend how the toilet tank functions when you're trying to answer “why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others”. The handle of the toilet flush triggers a chain, which then raises a rubber flapper at the base of the tank when you flush it. This enables waste to be flushed away by water flowing from the tank into the bowl. The fill valve opens when the water drains from the tank, filling it with water so that it is prepared for the subsequent flush.

Signs of Low Toilet Water Levels

There are a number of signs when a toilet tank's water level is low that are important in learning about the answers to why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others. A weak or insufficient flush is the most noticeable indication. Lack of water in the tank will result in insufficient pressure to adequately flush the waste down the drain. Moreover, you might notice that after each flush, the toilet bowl doesn't fill up with as much water as it formerly did. Third, because there isn't enough water to effectively flush the waste away, you can have clogs more frequently.

Ways to Check and Repair a Low Water Level Issue

If you believe that there is not enough water in your toilet tank, there are a few things you may do to check and resolve the issue. The tank lid should be taken off in order to monitor the water level. The water should be at or just above the top of the overflow tube, not above it. Adjust the fill valve by turning the screw on top of the valve counterclockwise to raise the water level if it is too low.

If changing the fill valve doesn't fix the issue, the handle or the pipework may be malfunctioning. It's essential to hire a plumber in this situation to identify and resolve the issue of “why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others”. Low water levels in toilet tanks should never be ignored because doing so could result in more serious plumbing problems in the future.

Cause 2: Clogged or Obstructed Toilet Trap

Even if you have the best flushing toilets, a blocked or clogged toilet trap is another typical source of toilet issues. Just below the toilet bowl, there is a curved piping portion called the toilet trap. Its goal is to maintain a water seal around your property and keep sewage gases out in order to stop leaks. The trap can clog or become blocked, which can stop water from flowing through the toilet and lead to a number of issues. The toilet trap is a curved portion of the plumbing that is located immediately below the toilet bowl. It's intended to produce a water seal that keeps sewage gases out of your house. The trap is also in charge of diverting garbage and water into the sewage or septic system from the drainpipe and this is why you're reading this article on why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others.

Toilet Trap Signs of Clogging or Obstruction

When you're finding the answer to “why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others,” you'll need to look for the signs of a toilet trap clog. Difficulty flushing is the most typical sign of a clogged or obstruction in the toilet trap. The toilet bowl may fill with water but not flush properly, or the water may drain slowly. Moreover, you might hear gurgling coming from the toilet or smell a bad stench. If the situation is more serious, the toilet may overflow, resulting in water damage and other health risks.

How to Deal with a Clogged Toilet Trap

There are a few measures you may take to examine and solve a clogged or obstructed trap problem if you believe your toilet trap is clogged or blocked. The initial step is to try to remove the impediment using a plunger. Using the plunger, make sure to seal the toilet bowl tightly and pump it up and down numerous times. If the plunger doesn't clear the obstruction, try using a plumbing snake. It's advisable to hire a plumber to identify and resolve the issue if it continues. The toilet trap may occasionally need to be replaced, cleaned, or both. It's important to take care of a clogged or blocked toilet trap as soon as you can because waiting can result in more serious plumbing issues in the future.

Cause 3: Faulty Flapper or Valve

The flapper or fill valve is an essential part of the flushing system of toilets. When the flush lever is depressed, the flapper rises, allowing water to flow from the tank to the bowl. Following the flush, the fill valve is in charge of filling the tank with water. The toilet's flushing system may have issues if the flapper or valve is broken which could be why you're looking up why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others.

Signs of a Faulty Flapper or Valve

The toilet running continuously, water spilling from the tank into the bowl, or a weak flush are all signs of a bad flapper or valve.

How to Deal with a Faulty Valve or Flapper

Start by cutting off the water supply to the toilet and flushing the toilet to empty the tank before inspecting and repairing a defective flapper or valve. Look for any damage or warping in the flapper, and replace it if necessary. If the fill valve is the issue, you should either change the tank's water level or replace the valve entirely. It's a good idea to look for any obstructions in the sewer line and toilet bowl that might be the source of the issue. To prevent further harm to your toilet or plumbing system, it is better to consult a professional plumber if you are unsure that you can remedy the issue.

Cause 4: Damaged or Faulty Toilet Handle

A broken or malfunctioning toilet handle can affect how the toilet flushes, resulting in problems like insufficient flushing or frequent obstructions which is why you can also learn how to flush a toilet without a handle. The tank of the toilet, which is in charge of holding and releasing water throughout the flush cycle, must have the toilet handle as a crucial component.

The toilet may not operate properly if the handle is broken or malfunctioning. The toilet handle is attached to a lever that initiates the flush system inside the toilet tank. This is how the toilet handle functions in the flush process. When you press down on the handle, a chain is raised, which releases a valve at the tank's bottom and lets water stream into the bowl and flush waste away. The position of the handle controls how much water is released, which impacts the flush's force.

Signs of a Broken or Defective Toilet Handle

Why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others? It could by a broken or defective handle. As you try to flush the toilet, you could notice that the handle feels flimsy or unsteady, or it might not bounce back up when you push it down. Incomplete flushing is another possibility, wherein not enough water is used to completely remove the waste from the toilet bowl. Finally, if the water pressure isn't sufficient to flush the waste down the drain, you can frequently suffer obstructions.

How to Diagnose and Repair a Damaged or Faulty Handle Issue

There are a few things you may take to check for damage or a malfunctioning toilet handle before fixing it. Remove the tank lid first, then look for any obvious damage to the handle. Check the chain connecting the handle to the flush mechanism if everything appears to be in order. Check the chain to make sure it isn't too loose or tight, as this could weaken the flush.

You might need to repair the handle or chain if they are damaged. Most hardware stores and home improvement stores provide replacement handles and chains. Just unplug the previous handle and chain and install the new ones.

It's advisable to hire a plumber to identify and resolve the issue if it continues. Sometimes, the problem may be with the flushing system inside the toilet tank, which may need to be replaced or repaired by a professional. It's critical to take care of a broken or malfunctioning toilet handle as soon as possible because delaying maintenance can result in more serious plumbing issues in the future.

Cause 5: Faulty or Clogged Sewer Line

Problems with your toilet's flush can result from a broken or clogged sewage line. Because the sewage line is in charge of transporting waste and water away from your home, issues with it could affect the plumbing system as a whole.

The water and garbage from your toilet are flushed into the sewage line. The garbage is subsequently transported from your home through the sewer line to a septic tank or a public sewage system. Your toilet may not flush properly if the sewage line is broken or clogged, preventing the proper passage of waste and water.

Signs of a Malfunctioning or Clogged Sewer Line

Why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others? Here are indications that your sewer line may be broken or clogged:

  • When you flush, water backs up into the toilet bowl.
  • The toilet bowl's water level is lower than usual.
  • Water does not fill the toilet bowl as it should.
  • Your home's drains or the toilet are making gurgling noises.
  • sewage smells coming from your drains or toilet.

It's crucial to check your sewer line for any issues if you experience any of these symptoms.

How to Diagnose and Repair a Broken or Clogged Sewer Line

Cut off the toilet's water supply. The flapper should not be jammed open, so remove the toilet tank lid and inspect it. If the flapper is operating normally, try clearing the obstruction using a plunger. You might need to use an auger or snake to clean the sewer line if the plunger doesn't work.

You might need to contact a licensed plumber for assistance if you don't feel comfortable using an auger or snake or if the clog is too severe.

In order to stop future harm to your plumbing system, it's crucial to take care of any problems with your sewer line as soon as possible. You may take the necessary actions to rectify the issue and keep your plumbing system operating normally by understanding the function of the sewage line in your toilet's flush and being aware of the signs of a damaged or clogged sewer line.

Bottom Line: Why Does My Toilet Flush Sometimes and Not Others

For homeowners, inconsistent toilet flushing can be an annoying and unpleasant issue. Why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others? Low water pressure, a clogged drain, and a broken flapper or valve in the toilet tank are just a few of the typical reasons for this problem that we have identified in this article. Turning off the water supply to the toilet, checking for damage to the flapper and valve, and making sure the toilet bowl and sewage line are free of any blockages are all necessary steps in identifying and resolving these problems.

To avoid more damage and preserve adequate hygiene, it is essential to address these problems right away. Future toilet flushing issues can be avoided with routine maintenance and checks, such as cleaning the tank and bowl and replacing damaged parts. Remember, it's always advisable to call a qualified plumber for help if you're unsure of your capacity to handle the problem.

Why Does My Toilet Flush Sometimes and Not Others FAQs

Why does my toilet flush sometimes and not others?

Your toilet might not flush regularly for a few reasons. One frequent reason for weak or ineffective flushing, obstructions, and inadequate water in the toilet bowl is the low water level in the tank. Another reason is a blocked or obstructed toilet trap, which can make it difficult to flush, cause delayed drainage, and cause other problems by preventing water from flowing down the toilet. The flushing system can potentially have issues due to a broken flapper or fill valve, such as continuous running water, water spilling into the bowl from the tank, or the toilet not flushing at all.

How does the toilet tank function?

With each flush, the fill valve refills the toilet tank with the water required for flushing. A rubber flapper at the bottom of the tank is raised when the toilet handle is pushed, allowing water to flow into the bowl and flush waste away.

What symptoms indicate low toilet water levels?

Weak or insufficient flushing, a lack of water in the bowl with each flush, and frequent blockages are some indications that the toilet water level is low.

How can I diagnose and fix a low water level problem?

You can remove the tank lid and check the water level to see if there isn't enough water in your toilet tank. If it is too low, you can raise it by rotating the fill valve's top screw in a counterclockwise direction. You might need to contact a plumber to find the problem and fix it if adjusting the fill valve doesn't work.

What symptoms indicate a toilet trap that is blocked or obstructed?

A clogged or blocked toilet trap will have trouble flushing, slow draining, gurgling noises, and an unpleasant stench. In extreme circumstances, the toilet could overflow and result in water damage.

How can I deal with a clogged toilet trap?

You can try using a plunger or plumbing snake to clear the obstruction. It's best to employ a plumber to find the problem and fix it if these solutions don't work. Periodically, the toilet trap may require cleaning or replacement.

What symptoms indicate a malfunctioning flapper or fill valve?

Continuous running water, water pouring from the tank into the bowl, and no flushing at all are indications that a flapper or fill valve is malfunctioning.

Why do I need to clean out a blocked or clogged toilet trap?

Waiting can lead to more significant plumbing problems down the road, so it's crucial to take care of a clogged or blocked toilet trap as soon as you can.

Ryan Copley

Ryan Copley

Having spent years participating in bathroom, kitchen, and home renovations, Ryan uses this experience to write informative blog posts on a wide variety of home renovation and kitchen topics.

Related Articles

Download Free Chart Now!

Your email will be used only to confirm your request and to provide free kitchen information. By submitting your info on this form, you are agreeing to be contacted regarding your service request by means of email. This is no obligation form and doesn’t require you to purchase any service.